Nguyen Thi Phuc and her 3 children


Nguyen Thi Phuc and her 3 children were originally among 46 Vietnamese asylum seekers flown back to Vietnam after Australian authorities intercepted their boat on 21 July 2015 off the coast of Western Australia.

Upon their return to Vietnam, Mrs Phuc was fined and received a suspended sentence in a civil court for having participated in the trip, but was not charged as an organizer and did not serve time in jail.

Mrs Phuc said she and her children had fled Vietnam in the first place because the family had lost their livelihood due to Chinese incursions into fishing grounds but had nevertheless been penalized by having to pay higher taxes. She and her husband had also been the victims of violence, having been beaten by an attacker. The family also maintains there is institutionalized discrimination against Catholics and that they left in quest of religious freedom. Meanwhile, Mrs Phuc’s husband, Tran Van Yen, was recently released from jail in Indonesia, having been accused of fishing in Indonesian waters.

On the night of 31 January 2017, Mrs Phuc and her 3 children were among 18 asylum seekers, who fled Vietnam secretly by boat in a second attempt to reach Australia. On 10 February, however, their boat engine failed, the current carrying them into Indonesian waters, where the boat hit rocks and began to sink, resulting in them losing everything. Rescued off the Java coast by Indonesian authorities, they were interviewed by the UNHCR twice in an effort to gain refugee status in Indonesia.

(See “Fate of Vietnamese asylum seeker children hangs in the balance” by Shira Sebban, 16 March 2017,10117)

Australian crowd fund donations once again supported the group initially in Indonesia, paying for hostel accommodation and meals for all of them plus 2 security guards for several days, and thereby preventing them from being deported immediately to Vietnam and giving them a chance to be interviewed by the UNHCR.

Unfortunately, this was not sustainable long-term, as funds needed to be conserved for the children’s future. So the family is now dependent on Indonesian immigration and the IOM (International Organization for Migration).

We know through the family’s lawyer Don An Vo ( and Tran Thi Thanh Loan’s sister, Thuy Trong, in Vietnam that when police discovered they were missing, they set up roadblocks around La Gi village, checking everyone who entered and left. The police also harassed the extended family, wanting to know the details of their escape. A family member described the police action to Australia’s SBS news.

(Women flee Vietnam for second time following turn-back from Australia” by Joel Keep and Mai Hoa Pham, 15 February 2017

The family was granted refugee status by the UNHCR while in detention in Jakarta on 5 May 2017. They are now awaiting resettlement in a  third country, which could still take a long time.





Previous articleGia đình ông Nguyen Tuan Kiet
Next articleAmnesty International Public Statement
I am a writer and editor, passionate about helping refugees and about exploring the challenges life throws at us through my writing. A former journalist, I previously worked in publishing and taught French to university students. I am a member of Supporting Asylum Seekers Sydney (SASS) and have also served on the board of my children’s school for the past 13 years, including three terms as vice-president. My work has appeared in online and print publications including The Sydney Morning Herald, The Guardian, Independent Australia, New Matilda, Eureka Street, Jewish Literary Journal, The Forward and Online Opinion. I can be contacted at Tôi là nhà văn/nhà báo, và cũng là chủ bút. Với nhiệt tâm muốn giúp đỡ cho người tị nạn và tìm hiểu sâu xa hơn về những khó khăn trong cuộc sống mà chúng ta phải đương đầu qua những bài viết của tôi. Là một cựu phóng viên, trước đây tôi từng cho phát hành các ấn phẩm và đã từng dạy môn Pháp ngữ cho sinh viên đại học. Tôi là thành viên của Tổ chức Giúp đỡ Người Tầm Trú Sydney (Supporting Asylum Seekers Sydney, SASS); và trong 13 năm qua, tôi cũng là thành viên trong ban đại diện hội phụ huynh học sinh của trường các con tôi học, với ba nhiệm kỳ làm phó chủ tịch. Những bài viết của tôi được đăng trên báo và trên trang mạng của những tờ báo như The Sydney Morning Herald, The Guardian, Independent Australia, New Matilda, Eureka Street, Jewish Literary Journal, The Forward and Online Opinion. Để liên lạc với tôi, xin gởi email đến địa chỉ