Fears returned Vietnamese asylum seekers are being grilled in police detention


Immigration Minister Peter Dutton. Photo: Andrew Meares

Heath Aston
APRIL 23 2015

Asylum seekers who were returned to Vietnam by the Australian Navy last week are believed to be being interrogated at a police-run detention centre in a coastal province north of Ho Chi Minh City.

According to sources in the Australian Vietnamese community, all adults who were on-board a boat intercepted somewhere north of Australia have been detained for questioning for the past week.

It is also believed that they left southern Vietnam in March – meaning Australian authorities potentially kept the group detained for weeks while their asylum claims were screened by Immigration Department officials on-board the HMAS Choules.

They were handed over to officials in Vung Tau, a southern port city, last Friday. Immigration Minister Peter Dutton confirmed for the first time on Thursday that 46 people had been returned.

A group of Tamils was kept on-board the Customs ship Ocean Protector for a month last year as the Abbott government tried to convince India to accept the Sri Lankan natives back.

The information about the group of 46 who left southern Vietnam has come via a Vietnamese asylum seeker currently inside a detention centre in Australia. Her nephew was on the intercepted boat.

Some members of the Vietnamese community in Melbourne were aware of the group’s plans to head to Australia by boat in March, Fairfax Media has learnt.

According to information relayed to Australia this week, the adults who were taken back to Vietnam on HMAS Choules are being held at a detention centre in the province of Binh Thuan while a number of minors have been released.

Separately, Anoop Sukumaran from the Asia Pacific Refugee Rights Network in Bangkok said he had received reports that the group were still in police custody but could not confirm the information they are being held in Binh Thuan.

“We have heard something similar,” he told Fairfax Media.

The group was handed over to Vietnamese officials in Vung Tau, about 100 kilometres south east of Ho Chi Minh City. Phan Thiet, the provincial capital of Binh Thuan, is more than 200 kilometres east of Ho Chi Minh.

According to the state-run Bin Thuan Online, there is a “temporary police detention centre” in Phan Thiet. The publication boasted in August 2013 about how “ebullient and aggressive” youth had been “enlightened” by the centre’s police superintendents before being released as part of a national amnesty.

“Amid the joyful atmosphere of the nationwide amnesty under the State President’s decision, the temporary detention centre of Binh Thuan Police solemnly held ceremony to announce amnesty decision to offenders who had good behaviors [sic] during the process of doing porridge,” it states.

Trong Doan, a Vietnamese Australian refugee advocate and former community leader, said it was no secret that detention centres and re-education camps were used across Vietnam to interrogate suspected political subversives.

He said it was likely that security officials would be sent to Binh Thuan from Hanoi, the Communist Party capital in the north of the country.

“What usually happens is people are asked the same question again and again and again. If people are charged they will go to prison. The Communist Party runs the courts. They run everything, all the newspapers and all the NGOs,” he said.

Mr Doan said Vietnamese Australians were concerned at the secrecy that has surrounded the hand-back. “This type of secrecy is normally reserved for terrorism and national security not for a group of people who are tired and weak on a boat journey.”

Amnesty International has said that the asylum claims of the Vietnamese cannot have been adequately assessed and determined by government officials at sea.

Mr Dutton, who publicly thanked the Vietnamese government on Thursday, said last year’s High Court decision mean Australia was within its rights to screen people at sea and said he was satisfied those returned would not face state persecution.

“We can’t trace people back through countries for the rest of their natural life – that hasn’t happened under any program. But we assure ourselves of the fact that people aren’t returning to persecution or to a difficult situation,” he said.

“We have worked with the Vietnamese in relation to this issue and I want to say thank you to the Vietnamese government for the constructive way in which they have been able to work with us. We have been able to safely return those 46 people to Vietnam.”

First published in the SMH, 23/04/2015

Previous articleTony Abbott tight-lipped on suspected Vietnamese asylum seeker boat
Next articleAustralia returned 46 asylum seekers to Vietnam, says immigration minister
I am a writer and editor, passionate about helping refugees and about exploring the challenges life throws at us through my writing. A former journalist, I previously worked in publishing and taught French to university students. I am a member of Supporting Asylum Seekers Sydney (SASS) and have also served on the board of my children’s school for the past 13 years, including three terms as vice-president. My work has appeared in online and print publications including The Sydney Morning Herald, The Guardian, Independent Australia, New Matilda, Eureka Street, Jewish Literary Journal, The Forward and Online Opinion. I can be contacted at sebban@tpg.com.au Tôi là nhà văn/nhà báo, và cũng là chủ bút. Với nhiệt tâm muốn giúp đỡ cho người tị nạn và tìm hiểu sâu xa hơn về những khó khăn trong cuộc sống mà chúng ta phải đương đầu qua những bài viết của tôi. Là một cựu phóng viên, trước đây tôi từng cho phát hành các ấn phẩm và đã từng dạy môn Pháp ngữ cho sinh viên đại học. Tôi là thành viên của Tổ chức Giúp đỡ Người Tầm Trú Sydney (Supporting Asylum Seekers Sydney, SASS); và trong 13 năm qua, tôi cũng là thành viên trong ban đại diện hội phụ huynh học sinh của trường các con tôi học, với ba nhiệm kỳ làm phó chủ tịch. Những bài viết của tôi được đăng trên báo và trên trang mạng của những tờ báo như The Sydney Morning Herald, The Guardian, Independent Australia, New Matilda, Eureka Street, Jewish Literary Journal, The Forward and Online Opinion. Để liên lạc với tôi, xin gởi email đến địa chỉ sebban@tpg.com.au